Stephen A. Smith Launches Counterattack After ‘F’ Rating

Stephen A. Smith is pushing back after receiving a harsh public rebuke from the National Association of Black Journalists (NABJ). The nabj thumbs down stephen smith controversy began after the ESPN “First Take” host was given the organization’s annual “Thumbs Down” award at its convention Saturday, with the group criticizing what it described as a recurring pattern of disparaging comments about prominent Black women.

NABJ Criticizes Smith

The NABJ said Smith’s commentary has targeted Black women in politics, sports and media and argued that his remarks contribute to harmful narratives about Black women in public discourse. The organization said the criticism was inconsistent with its commitment to accurate, responsible and inclusive portrayals of Black communities.

The award represents a significant change in the relationship between Smith and the journalists organization. Smith had previously participated in NABJ conventions, including appearances and live broadcasts of his show in 2024 and 2025. The latest confrontation now puts the longtime relationship under considerable strain.

Smith Promises a Response

Smith quickly responded on social media, signaling that he does not intend to remain silent. He suggested that the NABJ had opened the door for him to respond publicly and warned that he planned to address issues involving the organization and the wider Black community. His comments indicated that a much broader response could be coming.

The dispute adds to a series of public clashes involving the outspoken sports commentator. Smith has previously criticized Democratic Rep. Jasmine Crockett, sparred with former television anchor Joy Reid and maintained a long-running feud with NBA star LeBron James. His increasingly frequent commentary on politics and culture has also expanded his profile beyond sports media.

A Wider Public Debate

The NABJ’s “Thumbs Down” award was not limited to Smith. Other recipients included Federal Communications Commission Chairman Brendan Carr, Circle City Broadcasting CEO DuJuan McCoy, CBS and the Washington Post. However, Smith’s response has drawn particular attention because of his previous relationship with the organization and his promise of a forceful rebuttal.

Smith has also hinted that he could pursue a political career, including a possible presidential run. His growing involvement in political discussions has made his public statements increasingly relevant outside the sports world. The latest confrontation with the NABJ could further intensify that profile as Smith prepares to respond to the criticism.

Source : latimes.com